Verg. Ecl. 9, 44-55: singers, songs, fiction of orality
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.14409/argos.2021.46.e0031Keywords:
Vergil, Eclogue 9, Bucolic poetry, Poeta, VatesAbstract
Regarding Verg. Ecl. 9, 44-55 the manuscript tradition is not uniform: most of the MSS assign vv. 46-50 to Meris; a few (M and γ) assign them to Lycidas. The article provides substantiation for the attribution of these verses to Lycidas; it reviews various solutions adopted in recent editions and commentaries, including the latest critical edition (Ottaviano., 2013), which (wrongly in our view) adopts the emendation nisi in v. 45. The four evocations of song made by Lycidas and Meris are then analysed within the framework of two timely points made by Schmidt (1972): a. the particular concept of ‘authorship’ that governs the fiction of orality proper to bucolic poetry; b. the relationship established in the eclogue between the content of these evocations and the categories of poeta and uates stated in vv. 32-36.
References
Álvarez Hernández, A. (2000). Sobre Verg. ecl. 9, 26-36, a propósito del motivo de la excusatio”. KHPOS. Homenaje a Eduardo J. Prieto, 71-78.
Blänsdorf, J. (1995). Fragmenta Poetarum Latinorum Epicorum et Lyricorum (editionem tertiam auctam curavit Jürgen Blänsdorf). Teubner [FLP].
Campbell Daintree, D. Ch. (1993). Scholia Bernensia. An Edition of the Scholia on the Eclogues of Virgil in Bern Burgerbibliothek Manuscript 172 (Tesis doctoral). University of Tasmania. https://eprints.utas.edu.au/19578/1/whole_DaintreeDavidCharlesCampbell1994_thesis.pdf
Clausen, W. (1994). Virgil. Eclogues (With an Introduction and Commentary by Wendell Clausen). OUP.
Coleman, R. (1977). Virgil. Eclogues. CUP.
Cucchiarelli, A. (2012). Publio Virgilio Marone. Le Bucoliche (Introduzione e commento di A. Cucchiarelli, traduzione di A. Traina). Carocci editore.
Klingner, F. (1967). Virgil. Bucolica, Georgica, Aeneis (Texte lateinisch und deustch. Einleitung und Kommentare). Artemis Vlg..
Mynors, R. A. B. (1972). Vergili Maronis. Opera. OUP.
Ottaviano, S. (2013). P. Vergilius Maro. Bucolica (Edidit et apparatu critico instruxit Silvia Ottaviano). Walter de Gruyter.
Perkell, C. (2001). Vergil Reading His Twentieth-Century Readers: A Study of Eclogue 9. Vergilius. The Journal of the Virgilian Society, 47, 64-88.
Ribbeck, O. (1857). Über die Komposition von Vergilius Eclogen. N. Jb. f. Phil. u. Paed. Jahrg. 27(75).
Schmidt, E. A. (1972). Poesia e política nella nona egloga di Virgilio. Maia, 24, 99-119.
