Re-theorising the progress of women in policing: an alternative perspective from the Global South
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.14409/dys.2022.54.e0073Keywords:
Southern criminology, women in policing, policing gender violence, women’s police stations, masculine police cultureAbstract
Women’s entry into policing, a traditionally masculine occupation, has been theorised almost entirely through a liberal feminist theoretical lens where equality with men is the end target. From this theoretical viewpoint, women’s police stations in the Global South established specifically to respond to gender violence have been conceptualised as relics from the past. We argue that this approach is based on a global epistemology that privileges the Global North as the normative benchmark from which to define progress. Framed by Southern criminology, we offer an alternative way of theorising the progress of women in policing using women’s police stations that emerged in Latin America in the 1980s, specifically those in the Province of Buenos Aires, Argentina.
References
Amaral S, Bhalotraz S y Prakash N (2018) Gender, crime and punishment: Evidence from women police stations in India. Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) through the Research Centre on Micro-Social Change (MiSoC) at the University of Essex.
Aas KF (2012) ‘The Earth is one but the world is not’: Criminological theory and its geopolitical divisions. Theoretical Criminology, 16(1), 5–20.
Asher K (2017) Spivak y Rivera Cusicanqui on the dilemmas of representation in postcolonial and decolonial feminisms. Feminist Studies, 43(3), 512–524.
Atkinson C (2017) Patriarchy, gender, infantilisation: A cultural account of police intelligence work in Scotland. Australian & New Zealand Journal of Criminology, 50(2), 234–251.
Barry C (2007) El Partido Peronista Femenino: la gestación política y legal. Nuevo Mundo Mundos Nuevos, debates. Accesible en: https://doi.org/10.4000/nuevomundo.12382.
Barry C (2009) Claves y estrategias de inclusión política de mujeres en el peronismo: Su análisis desde un barrio singular de Buenos Aires (1946–1955). Revista SAAP: Sociedad Argentina de Análisis Político, 3(3), 635–662.
Barry C (2011) Eva Perón y la organización política de las mujeres. Working Paper, 453. Universidad del Centro de Estudios Macroeconómicos de Argentina.
Brown J (1997) European policewomen: A comparative research perspective. International Journal of the Sociology of Law, 25(1), 1–19.
Brown J (2007) From cult of masculinity to smart macho: Gender perspectives on police occupational culture. In: O’Neill M, Marks M and Singh A-M (eds) Police Occupational Culture (205-226). Bingley: Emerald Group Publishing Limited.
Brown J, Hazenberg A y Ormiston C (1999) Policewomen: An international comparison. In: Mawby RI (ed.) Policing across the World: Issues for the Twenty-First Century (204-225). New York: Routledge.
Brown J, Hegarty P y O’Neill D (2006) Playing with numbers: A discussion paper on positive discrimination as means for achieving gender equality in the police service in England and Wales. Review commissioned by British Association for Women in Policing. School of Human Sciences, Department of Psychology, University of Surrey.
Brown J y Heidensohn F (2000) Gender and Policing: Comparative Perspectives. Basingstoke: Macmillan.
Brown J y Silvestri M (2020) A police service in transformation: Implications for women police officers. Police Practice and Research, 21(5), 459–475.
Brown M (2018) Southern criminology in the post-colony: More than a ‘derivative discourse’? In: Carrington K, Hogg R and Scott J, et al. (eds) The Palgrave Handbook of Criminology and the Global South (83-104). Chambourd: Palgrave Macmillan.
Calandrón S (2008) Cultura institucional y problematicas de genero en la Reforma de la Policia de Buenos Aires, 2004–2007. Tesina final de Carrera, Licentura en Sociologia, Universidad de La Plata, La Plata, Buenos Aires.
Calandrón S (2014) Género y sexualidad en la Policía Bonaerense. San Martin: UNSAM Edita.
Calandrón S (2019) Minitas luchadoras: género y políticas públics en estudios empíricos sobre las fuerzas policiales argentinas. Revista Sudamericana, 11, 17–35.
Calandrón S y Galeano D (2013) La ‘Brigada Femenina’: Incorporacion de mujeres a la Policia de la Provincia de Buenos Aires (1947–1955). En: Salvatore R and Barreneche O (eds) El Delito y el Orden en Perspectiva Historica (167-186). Rosario: Prohistoria Edicionaes.
Carrington K, Hogg R y Sozzo M (2016) Southern criminology. The British Journal of Criminology, 56(1), 1–20.
Carrington K, Sozzo M, Puyol MV, et al. (2019) The role of women’s police stations in responding to and preventing gender violence, Buenos Aires, Argentina: Stage 1 Report ARC Project (unpublished).
Carrington K, Sozzo M, Ryan V, et al. (2021) Women-led police stations: Reimagining the policing of gender violence in the 21st century. Policing and Society. Epub ahead of print 30 July 2021. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10439463.2021.1956925.
Cavaler CM y Macarini SM (2020) Rethinking practices: Women’s police station as a dialogic space for preventing conjugal violence. Nova Perspectiva Sistêmica, 29(66), 60–73.
Chu DC (2013) Gender integration in policing: A comparison of male and female police officers’ perceptions in Taiwan. International Journal of Comparative and Applied Criminal Justice, 37(2), 143–157.
Connell R (2007) Southern Theory: The Global Dynamics of Knowledge Social Science. Crow’s Nest: Allen & Unwin.
Connell R (2014) Rethinking gender from the Global South. Feminist Studies, 40(3), 518–539.
Connell R (2015) Meeting at the edge of fear: Theory on a world scale. Feminist Theory, 16(1), 49– 66.
Córdova A y Kras H (2020) Addressing violence against women: The effect of women’s police stations on police legitimacy. Comparative Political Studies, 53(5), 775–808.
De Sousa Santos B (2014) Epistemologies of the South: Justice against Epistemicide. Boulder, CO: Paradigm Publishers.
Douglas H (2019) Policing domestic and family violence. International Journal for Crime, Justice and Social Democracy, 8(2), 31–49.
Eisenstein Z (1981) The Radical Future of Liberal Feminism. Boston, MA: Northeastern University Press.
Flately J (2020) Police workforce, England and Wales, as of 31 March 2020. Home Office Statistical Bulletin 20. London: Home Office.
Goodmark L (2021) Gender-based violence, law reform, and the criminalization of survivors of violence. International Journal for Crime, Justice and Social Democracy, 10(4), 13–25.
Gruba A (2020) The Feminist War on Crime: The Unexpected Role of Women’s Liberation in Mass Incarceration. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Haberfeld M y Gideon L (2008) Introduction: Policing is hard on democracy, or democracy is hard on policing? In: Haberfeld M and Cerrah I (eds) Comparative Policing: The Struggle for Democratization. Los Angeles, CA: SAGE, 2–9.
Hautzinger S (2002) Criminalising male violence in Brazil’s women’s police stations: From flawed essentialism to imagined communities. Journal of Gender Studies, 11(3), 243–251.
Hautzinger S (2020) Responding to crime victims and community needs: Nongendered versus specialized women’s units. In: Rabe-Hemp C and Garcia V (eds) Women Policing across the Globe: Shared Challenges and Successes in the Integration of Women Police Worldwide (143-162). London: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
Heidensohn F (1989) Women in Policing in the USA. London: Police Foundation.
Humiston GS y Rabe-Hemp C (2020) The progression of women police: A comparative analysis. In: Rabe-Hemp C and Garcia V (eds) Women Policing across the Globe: Shared Challenges and Successes in the Integration of Women Police Worldwide (11-27). London: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
Jardine M (2018) Gender equality and the role of women in policing in Vietnam. The People’s Police Journal, 3(13). Hanoi: Ministry of Public Security.
Jardine M (2019a) A southern policing perspective and appreciative inquiry: An ethnography of policing in Vietnam. Policing and Society, 30(2), 186–205.
Jardine M (2019b) Women in Law Enforcement Institutions in Five Mekong Countries (Myanmar, Vietnam, Thailand, Cambodia & Lao PDR). Bangkok: UNODC & UN Women.
Jubb N, Camacho G, Almachiara DA, et al. (2008) Regional mapping study of women’s police stations in Latin America. Quito, Ecuador: CEPLAES.
Jubb N, Comacho G, D’Angelo A, et al. (2010) Women’s police stations in Latin America: An entry point for stopping violence and gaining access to justice. Quito, Ecuador: CEPLAES, IDRC.
Kanter RM (1977a) Men and Women of the Corporation. New York: Basic Books.
Kanter RM (1977b) Some effects of proportions on group life. American Journal of Sociology, 82(5), 965–990.
Kavanaugh G, Sviatschi MM y Trako I (2018) Female officers, gender violence and human capital: Evidence from all-women’s justice centers in Peru. PSE Working Papers halshs-01828539.
Larson C (ed.) (2020) The Conquest of the Desert: Argentina’s Indigenous Peoples and the Battle for History. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press.
Lee H y Liebenau J (2000) Time and the internet at the turn of the millennium. Time & Society, 9(1), 43–56.
MacDowell Santos C (2005) Women’s Police Stations: Gender, Violence, and Justice in São Paulo, Brazil. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Magalhães Gomes C (2021) Notes on gender, race and punishment from a decolonial perspective to a southern criminology agenda. International Journal for Crime, Justice and Social Democracy, 10(4), 90–101.
Mateveke P (2019) ‘If we must be freaks, let us be freaks with a voice’: Southern feminisms and LGBTI activism in Africa. Agenda (Durban, South Africa), 33(3), 78–86.
Mathrubhumi (2018) First women police station in India turns 45 on Saturday. 26 October. Available at: https://english.mathrubhumi.com/news/kerala/first-women-police-station-in- india-turns-45-on-saturday-kozhikode-1.3254855.
Mawby RI (1999) Approaches to comparative analysis: The impossibility of becoming an expert on everywhere. In: Mawby RI (ed.) Policing across the World: Issues for the Twenty-First Century (13-22). New York: Routledge.
Melossi D (2001) The cultural embeddedness of social control: Reflections on the comparison of Italian and North-American cultures concerning punishment. Theoretical Criminology, 5(4), 403–424.
Melossi D, Sozzo M y Sparks R (2011) Introduction. Criminal questions: Cultural embeddedness and diffusion. In: Melossi D, Sozzo M and Sparks R (eds) Travels of the Criminal Question: Cultural Embeddedness and Diffusion (1-14). Oxford: Hart.
Mignolo W (2011) The Darker Side of Western Modernity: Global Future, Decolonial Options. Durham, NC: Duke University Press Books.
Mignolo W (2012) Local Histories/Global Designs: Coloniality, Subaltern Knowledges, and Border Thinking. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Mohanty C (1984) Under western eyes: Feminist scholarship and colonial discourses. Boundary 2, 12(3), 333–358.
Mohanty C (2003) Feminism without Borders: Decolonizing Theory, Practicing Solidarity. Durham, NC: Duke University Press Books.
Moosavi L (2019) Decolonising criminology: Syed Hussein Alatas on crimes of the powerful. Critical Criminology, 27(2), 229–242.
Morash M, Kwak D-H y Haarr R (2006) Gender differences in the predictors of police stress. Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management, 29(3), 541–563.
Murray SE (2021) Seeing and doing gender at work: A qualitative analysis of Canadian male and female police officers. Feminist Criminology, 16(1), 91–109.
Murray T (2020) Women policing across the globe: Shared challenges and successes in the integration of women police worldwide [Book Review]. Police Practice and Research, 21(5), 543–544.
Natarajan M (2005) Women police stations as a dispute processing system. Women & Criminal Justice, 16(1–2), 87–106.
Natarajan M (2008) Women Police in a Changing Society: Back Door to Equality. London: Routledge.
Natarajan M y Babu D (2020) Women police stations: Have they fulfilled their promise? Police Practice and Research, 21(5), 442–458.
Newton K y Huppatz K (2020) Policewomen’s perceptions of gender equity policies and initiatives in Australia. Feminist Criminology, 15(5), 593–610.
Pasinato W (2016) The Maria Da Penha Law: 10 years on. Sur: International Journal on Human Rights, 13(24), 155–163.
Perova E y Reynolds SA (2017) Women’s police stations and intimate partner violence: Evidence from Brazil. Social Science & Medicine, 174, 188–196.
Porter LE y Prenzler T (2019) Exploring gender differences in the Australian context: Organizational and cultural dimensions of ethical attitudes. In: Kutnjak Ivković S and Haberfeld MR (eds) Exploring Police Integrity: Novel Approaches to Police Integrity Theory and Methodology (287-312). Cham: Springer International Publishing.
Prenzler T (2020) Remarks by the guest editor. Police Practice and Research, 21(5), 439–441.
Prenzler T y Sinclair G (2013) The status of women police officers: An international review. International Journal of Law, Crime and Justice, 41(2), 115–131.
Queensland Death Review (2017) Domestic and Family Violence Death Review and Advisory Board 2016–17 annual report. Brisbane: Queensland Government.
Rabe-Hemp CE (2020) The status of women police across the globe: Women’s voices from the field. In: Rabe-Hemp C and Garcia V (eds) Women Policing across the Globe: Shared Challenges and Successes in the Integration of Women Police Worldwide (3-9). London: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
Reiner R (2010) The Politics of the Police. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Royal Commission into Family Violence (2016) Report and Recommendations, Volume III. Victoria: State of Victoria.
Seklecki R y Paynich R (2007) A national survey of female police officers: An overview of findings. Police Practice and Research, 8(1), 17–30.
Shahjahan RA (2015) Being ‘lazy’ and slowing down: Toward decolonizing time, our body, and pedagogy. Educational Philosophy and Theory, 47(5), 488–501.
Shen A (2020) Women policing in China: Separate but equal? In: Rabe-Hemp C and Garcia V (eds) Women Policing across the Globe: Shared Challenges and Successes in the Integration of Women Police Worldwide (67-84). London: Rowman & Littlefield.
Silverman EK (2001) Anthropology of time. In: Smelser NJ and Baltes PB (eds) International Encyclopedia of the Social & Behavioral Sciences. Oxford: Pergamon, 15683–15686.
Silvestri M (2017) Police culture and gender: Revisiting the ‘cult of masculinity’. Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice, 11(3), 289–300.
State Coroner (Fogliani, Rosalinda Vincenza Clorinda) (2016) Inquest into the Death of Julieka Ivanna DHU (11020-14). Perth: Western Australia Coroners Courts.
Strobl S (2008) The Women’s Police Directorate in Bahrain: An ethnographic exploration of gender segregation and the likelihood of future integration. International Criminal Justice Review, 18(1), 39–58.
Strobl S (2010) Progressive or neo-traditional? Policewomen in Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) countries. Feminist Formations, 22(3), 51–74.
Strobl S (2020) Women and policing in Kuwait: Deferring gender inclusion. In: Rabe-Hemp C and Garcia V (eds) Women Policing across the Globe: Shared Challenges and Successes in the Integration of Women Police Worldwide (49-66). London: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
Tlostanova M, Thapar-Björkert S y Koobak R (2017) Border thinking and disidentification: Postcolonial and postsocialist feminist dialogues. Feminist Theory, 17(2), 211–228.
Tong R y Botts TF (2018) Feminist Thought: A More Comprehensive Introduction. London: Routledge.
Tuhiwai Smith L (2001) Decolonizing Methodologies: Research and Indigenous Peoples. London: Zed Books.
Uchendu U, Roets G y Vandenbroeck M (2019) Mapping constructs of gender in research on Igbo women in Nigeria: Embracing a southern feminist theoretical perspective. Gender and Education, 31(4), 508–524.
Valdés-Riesco A (2021) Can the subaltern speak in criminology? Analysing the production of knowledge on crimes of the powerful in the 21st century through Latin American postcolonial lenses. International Journal for Crime, Justice and Social Democracy, 10(1), 30–51.
Victorian Equal Opportunity and Human Rights Commission (VEO) (2015) Independent review into sex discrimination and sexual harassment, including predatory behaviour, in Victoria Police: Phase one report. Carlton: Victoria.
Ward A y Prenzler T (2016) Good practice case studies in the advancement of women in policing. International Journal of Police Science & Management, 18(4), 242–250.
World Atlas (2022) https://www.worldatlas.com/continents/south-america.html (accessed 7 February 2022).
